Request an Audit
General information
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Cookie Consent

By clicking “Accept”, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. View our Privacy Policy for more information.

Cookie preferences
Daniel Francis

Importance of Proof of Reserve Audits in 2023

What is a Proof of Reserve Audit? 

A Proof of Reserve Audit is an audit that verifies the amount of cryptocurrency held by an exchange or other entity. It is used to guarantee that the company is not overstating its cryptocurrency holdings and that customer funds are not mismanaged and are backed up by real assets. The audit typically involves a third-party auditor examining the entity's records and verifying the amount of cryptocurrency held. This article will discuss the importance of proof of reserve audits in 2023 and how it can help ensure the security and integrity of digital assets.

In 2008 the recession was caused by the subprime mortgage market, fueled by irresponsible lending practices. Banks were eventually bailed out of their bad decisions by the government.

With little explanation, $8B in customers' funds vanished in a week. Centralized exchanges are meant to keep funds secure, but Samuel Bankman-Fried  (SBF) treated it as their own "piggybank" and gambled it away. A Proof of Reserve audit should be the industry standard for evaluating the checks and balances of crypto exchanges and DeFi platforms in the wake of the FTX catastrophe. The government doesn’t step in to bail out centralized exchanges if they mismanage user funds.

As a result, everyone scrambled to identify a solution and Proof of Reserve emerged as the most popular one. The hope is that once exchanges implement this method of asset verification, there wouldn't be a repeat of the FTX drama and users' funds being used as a slush fund. According to Cer.Live exchanges are already sharing any proof of reserve information they can in the aftermath to distance themselves from FTX, such as Kraken, Gate.io, Binance, KuCoin, and OKX

Why is a Proof of Reserve Audit Important in Web3? 

How to implement a Proof of Reserve Audit?   

It can be more complex than this, but this is the general idea of how it can be done in practice. To implement a Proof of Reserve Audit, the entity must first provide a list of all its addresses. This list should include the address, the amount of cryptocurrency held, and the date the address was created. The entity should also provide a list of all transactions that have taken place on the addresses. 

The auditor must also ensure that the exchange owns all the addresses they gave. A blockchain explorer can be used to verify the amount of cryptocurrency held in each address. The auditor should also check the transaction history to ensure that the transactions are legitimate. After confirming the amount of cryptocurrency stored at each address, the auditor should compare the amount held to the amount reported by the entity. If the amounts match, the audit is successful. If the amounts do not match, the audit has failed, and the entity must explain the discrepancy.

Why is proof reserve audits in crypto exchanges hard for traditional auditing firms? 

Traditional auditing firms need to become more familiar with the technology and processes used in crypto exchanges, making it difficult to audit the proof reserve. Crypto exchanges use various technologies, such as blockchain, smart contracts, and distributed ledgers, which are not typically used in traditional accounting. Additionally, the decentralized nature of crypto exchanges makes it challenging to track and verify transactions, making it difficult for conventional accounting firms to accurately audit the proof reserve.

The Future of Proof of Reserve Audits in Web3  

In crypto, we need to hold ourselves accountable. We don't have the luxury of government bailouts when companies behave irresponsibly with our funds. The future of proof of reserve audits in a crypto exchange is likely to become more important as the industry matures. As the industry grows, more exchanges will likely be required to provide proof of reserve audits to ensure that customer funds are secure and that the exchange operates in a compliant manner. This will undoubtedly entail using blockchain technology to offer a secure and transparent audit trail. Smart contracts and other automated procedures may also be used to guarantee that the exchange complies with standards and that customer money is protected. Customers must believe that protocols and institutions genuinely own the assets they claim for the industry to succeed.

About AuditOne

At AuditOne, we are committed to making security audits more accessible through our smart contract platform. Our team is passionate about the advancement of Web3 products and their security. We are a combination of industry experts and academics in the DeFi space. We want to reduce long waiting lists, high prices, and audit mismatches with projects by building the best platform for finding and booking certified smart contract auditors.

Back to Blog